SimpliFire GI-32-ZC 32" Electric Fireplace Insert

Ultimate Showdown: Electric vs. Wood-Burning vs. Gas Fireplaces

Are you ready to ignite the ultimate showdown?

Whether you crave the crackling charm of a wood-burning fireplace, the sleek efficiency of gas, or the modern versatility of electric, we've got you covered! This guide will help you compare and choose the perfect fireplace to keep you warm and cozy.

Dive into our side-by-side comparison to discover the pros and cons, costs, efficiency, and ideal applications of each type of fireplace. Let's find out which fireplace will be the heart of your home!

Table of Contents

Side-by-Side Comparison

Category

Electric Fireplaces

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Gas Fireplaces

Overview

Advanced technologies like LED lighting and faux flame effects

Traditional operation using wood logs and a chimney

Realistic flames using natural gas or propane

Key Features

Customizable flame effects, heating capabilities, remote controls, smart features

Authentic flames and crackling sounds, radiant heat

Realistic flames, efficient heat output, remote controls, smart features

Pros

Easy installation, low maintenance, energy efficient, safe

Authentic ambiance, can function during power outages

Convenient, easy to use, low maintenance, consistent heat output

Cons

Lack of authentic flame and sound, dependent on electricity

High maintenance, requires wood storage, emissions

Requires gas line installation, less authentic than wood-burning

Cost and Efficiency

Low initial cost, energy-efficient operation

High initial cost, ongoing cost for wood supply

Moderate initial cost, ongoing cost for gas

Suitable Applications

Apartments, condos, modern interiors

Rustic, traditional homes, areas with easy access to firewood

Modern, contemporary homes, areas with natural gas access

Ambiance and Aesthetics

Customizable but not entirely authentic

Highly authentic

Realistic but not as authentic as wood-burning

Heating Efficiency

Moderate, good for supplemental heat

High, primary or supplemental heat

High, primary or supplemental heat

Installation and Maintenance

Simple, no chimney required, low maintenance

Complex, requires chimney, high maintenance

Moderate, requires gas line, low maintenance

Environmental Impact

Low emissions, energy-efficient

High emissions, environmental concerns

Moderate emissions, cleaner than wood-burning

Safety Considerations

Safe, no real flames, no emissions

Fire hazard, requires proper ventilation

Safe with proper installation, requires ventilation

Pros and Cons

Electric Fireplaces

Continental Linear 100" Wall Mount Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Continental Linear 100" Wall Mount Electric Fireplace

Pros

Cons

Check Mark Easy Installation: Electric fireplaces do not need gas lines, chimneys, and venting systems. They only need a standard electrical outlet.

Check Mark Use Anytime: You can use electric fireplaces year-round due to their ability to display flames without the heating element being turned on. This allows you to enjoy the cozy ambiance without the added heat.

Check Mark Low Maintenance: Clean-up is easy when using electric fireplaces as they do not produce any soot or ash. They require very minimal maintenance and occasional check-ups of the LED lights.

Check Mark Safe: Due to the lack of real flames, electric fireplaces are much safer than gas fireplaces. This also eliminates the risk of accidental fires and carbon monoxide poisoning.

Check Mark Efficient: Electric fireplaces can convert 100% of the energy they use to heat, making them more energy-efficient than traditional or gas fireplaces. 

Cross Mark Supplemental Heating: Electric fireplaces are designed for decorative purposes and supplemental heating. This means that it has a comparatively lower heat output, making it unsuitable for heating large spaces or functioning as your home’s main source of heat.

Cross Mark Not As Authentic: Because electric fireplaces merely mimic the look and feel of real flames, they need more authenticity. It cannot recreate the sound, smell, and ambiance that a traditional or gas fireplace provides.

Cross Mark Electricity-Dependent: No electricity means no heating—that is essentially what you’re signing up for when you choose electric fireplaces. In the case of power outages, these fireplaces will not provide any value. They may also prove to be inconvenient especially when electricity gets cut off during the colder months.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Osburn Horizon Wood Fireplace including 4 Length of 6" x 36" Chimney

Pictured: Osburn Horizon Wood Fireplace including 4 Length of 6" x 36" Chimney

Pros

Cons

Check Mark Cozy Atmosphere: The crackling sound, natural scent, and flickering flames create a warm, inviting environment.

Check Mark Traditional Look: Enhances the rustic and classic charm of a home.

Check Mark Low Cost of Fuel: Firewood can be relatively inexpensive, especially if sourced locally or gathered from your property.

Check Mark Supplemental Heating: Can serve as an additional heat source, reducing reliance on central heating systems.

Check Mark Renewable Resource: Wood is a renewable energy source when harvested sustainably.

Check Mark Carbon Neutral: Burning wood releases carbon dioxide that trees have absorbed during their growth, making it relatively carbon neutral compared to fossil fuels.

Check Mark Off-Grid Heating: Provides a reliable heat source during power outages or in remote locations without access to other fuel types.

Cross Mark Maintenance and Cleaning: Regular ash removal and chimney sweeping to prevent creosote buildup.

Cross Mark Health and Safety Risks: Can release smoke and pollutants, risking respiratory health, fires, and carbon monoxide poisoning.

Cross Mark Efficiency and Draft Issues: Less efficient than modern systems; heat escapes up the chimney and can create drafts.

Cross Mark Installation and Compliance: Expensive and time-consuming; must comply with local building codes and permits.

Cross Mark Space and Labor Requirements: Needs space for firewood storage and physical effort to cut, split, and transport wood.

Gas Fireplaces

Empire 60 Boulevard Vent-Free Linear Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Empire 60 Boulevard Vent-Free Linear Gas Fireplace

Pros

Cons

Check Mark Real Flames: Offers the closest experience to a traditional fireplace without extensive maintenance and costly renovations. They produce real flames, creating an inviting and cozy atmosphere.

Check Mark Quick Heating: Generates large amounts of heat energy, making them highly efficient at heating large rooms or open areas quickly.

Check Mark Extremely Convenient: Often equipped with remote controls, switches, or thermostats, gas fireplaces allow you to start the fire with ease, eliminating the labor and time required for wood fireplaces.

Check Mark More Sustainable than Traditional Fireplaces: Produces fewer emissions, burns cleaner, and contributes less to air pollution.

Check Mark Low Maintenance: Produces no ash or soot, resulting in relatively low maintenance. They only require occasional cleaning to keep them in good working order.

Cross Mark Can Be Costly: Some requires remodeling or renovations for installation. Additionally, if your model requires extending gas lines, you may need to hire a professional to ensure it is done properly and safely, which can add to the overall cost.

Cross Mark Maintenance: While they have low clean-up and maintenance needs, it is recommended to inspect them annually and clean the vents and burner reservoir to ensure efficient operation.

Cross Mark Fuel Dependence: Relies on natural gas or propane. If the availability of these fuels decreases in your area, you won't be able to use the fireplace. Additionally, fluctuations in fossil fuel prices can impact operating costs.

Cross Mark Venting Requirements:  Produces smoke, necessitating a venting system to safely expel harmful emissions.

Cross Mark Not as Eco-Friendly:  Burning gas still produces pollutants, making gas fireplaces less environmentally friendly compared to electric fireplaces.

Which Fireplace to Choose?

Choose Electric if…

Dimplex 74" IgniteXL Linear Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Dimplex 74" IgniteXL Linear Electric Fireplace

  • You want something easy to install and maintain.
  • You want an appliance that can provide supplemental heating and aesthetics.
  • You prefer something cheaper and don’t mind the lower lifespan.
  • You don’t mind the simulated flames.
  • You have limited space with pets or kids.

Choose Wood-Burning if…

Majestic Biltmore 42" Radiant Traditional Wood Burning Fireplace With Traditional Brick Pattern

Pictured: Majestic Biltmore 42" Radiant Traditional Wood Burning Fireplace With Traditional Brick Pattern

  • You enjoy the traditional experience and sound of crackling wood.
  • You prefer the smell of burning wood.
  • You have access to a good supply of firewood.
  • You don’t mind the maintenance and cleaning required.
  • You want a high heat output for larger spaces.
  • You appreciate the ambiance and authentic flames of a real fire.

Choose Gas if…

Monessen 42" Exacta Vent Free Circulating Clean Face Firebox with Interior Panels

Pictured: Monessen 42" Exacta Vent Free Circulating Clean Face Firebox with Interior Panels

  • You want something that lasts a lifetime and has a longer warranty.
  • You prefer something with long-term and consistent heating.
  • You need something to quickly warm large areas.
  • You are willing to invest in its initial costs.
  • You don’t mind frequent maintenance.
  • You prefer the authentic flames and ambiance.

Understanding Electric, Gas, & Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Electric Fireplaces

Touchstone Chesmont 50" Wall Mount 3-Sided Smart Electric Fireplace (Alexa/Google Compatible)

Pictured: Touchstone Chesmont 50" Wall Mount 3-Sided Smart Electric Fireplace (Alexa/Google Compatible)

What is an Electric Fireplace?

An electric fireplace offers a modern and cost-effective alternative to traditional fireplaces. It delivers the aesthetic charm and heating efficiency of classic wood-burning fireplaces without wood or gas. 

Dimplex Featherston Stone Look 61" Mantel with 28" Electric Firebox

Pictured: Dimplex Featherston Stone Look 61" Mantel with 28" Electric Firebox

How Do Electric Fireplaces Work?

Electric fireplaces produce heat by using conductive materials like nickel-chromium alloys, often called nichrome, based on the principle of Joule heating. Electricity passing through these resistant materials turns into heat due to their inherent resistance to electron flow. The heat raises the temperature of a heating element.

A built-in fan distributes this warmth across the room. Additionally, the illusion of flickering flames is created using light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and reflective mirrors, mimicking the cozy ambiance of a traditional fireplace without actual combustion.

Different Types of Electric Fireplaces

SimpliFire Allusion Platinum 60" Linear Electric Recessed Fireplace

Pictured: SimpliFire Allusion Platinum 60" Linear Electric Recessed Fireplace

Linear: Sleek, modern design with a wide, horizontal flame. Ideal for contemporary homes, serving as a centerpiece in living rooms with a panoramic view of the flames.

Ambe Multi49 Left-Corner 48" Built-in Multi Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Ambe Multi49 Left-Corner 48" Built-in Multi Electric Fireplace

Built-In: Integrated into the wall for a custom look, blending seamlessly with the room's architecture. Can be installed at any height, offering versatile design options.

Amantii Tru-View XL Deep 72" Built-In Three Sided Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Amantii Tru-View XL Deep 72" Built-In Three Sided Electric Fireplace

Outdoor: Provides warmth and ambiance with realistic LED flames. These fireplaces are weather-resistant and perfect for patios and decks, offering a cozy, stylish focal point.

Napoleon CLEARion Elite 50" See Through Built-In Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Napoleon CLEARion Elite 50" See Through Built-In Electric Fireplace

See-Through: Visible from two rooms or sides, enhancing both indoor and outdoor aesthetics. Ideal for walls dividing rooms or exterior walls, providing warmth and visual appeal.

Dimplex Opti-Myst Pro 1000 46" Built-In Electric Firebox

Pictured: Dimplex Opti-Myst Pro 1000 46" Built-In Electric Firebox

Water Vapor: Uses water mist and LEDs to create a realistic flame look. Safe and energy-efficient, suitable for public places or homes without venting capabilities.

Dimplex Revillusion 36" Built-in Electric Firebox

Pictured: Dimplex Revillusion 36" Built-in Electric Firebox

Fireboxes: Core components containing the flames of the fireplace, made of metal or refractory materials. Essential for containing heat and maintaining safety during operation.

Modern Flames 36" Redstone Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert

Pictured: Modern Flames 36" Redstone Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert

Inserts: Designed to fit into existing fireplaces, retrofitting a wood-burning fireplace with a more efficient electric or gas unit while preserving the existing structure.

Sierra Flame by Amantii Cast Iron Freestanding 23"/28" Electric Stove

Pictured: Sierra Flame by Amantii Cast Iron Freestanding 23"/28" Electric Stove

Stoves: Freestanding units resembling traditional wood stoves, powered by various fuels like wood, gas, or electricity. Provide significant heat output with a charming design.

Napoleon Woodland 27" Electric Fireplace Log Set Insert

Pictured: Napoleon Woodland 27" Electric Fireplace Log Set Insert

Log Sets: Ceramic logs that offer a traditional look without burning wood, typically used in gas fireplaces. Provide the aesthetic of a real wood fire with the convenience of gas.

Bromic Heating 56" Tungsten Smart-Heat 6000 Watt Electric Patio Heater

Pictured: Bromic Heating 56" Tungsten Smart-Heat 6000 Watt Electric Patio Heater

Patio Heaters: Outdoor heaters extending the usability of outdoor spaces, available in stand-alone or wall-mounted designs. Fueled by propane or electricity for outdoor warmth.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Majestic 36" Royalton Radiant Traditional Wood Burning Fireplace

Pictured: Majestic 36" Royalton Radiant Traditional Wood Burning Fireplace

What is a Wood-Burning Fireplace?

A wood-burning fireplace is a traditional heating appliance that burns wood logs to generate heat. It has been a staple in homes for centuries, providing not only essential warmth but also a cozy and comforting atmosphere. The crackling sound of burning wood and the natural aroma contribute to its timeless appeal, making it a favored feature in many households.

Valcourt Saint-Laurent Decorative Linear Wood Fireplace

Pictured: Valcourt Saint-Laurent Decorative Linear Wood Fireplace

How Does a Traditional Fireplace Work?

Logs are placed on a grate in the firebox with kindling and tinder to help ignite the fire. A match or lighter is used to start the fire, with the kindling catching fire first, which then ignites the larger logs. As the wood burns, it reacts with oxygen, producing heat, light, carbon dioxide, and water vapor. The fire generates flames and glowing embers, creating a warm and inviting visual effect.

The firebox radiates heat into the room, with warm air rising and circulating to distribute heat evenly. Smoke and gases produced by the burning wood rise up through the flue within the chimney. The chimney's draft draws smoke and gases out of the house, preventing them from entering the living space.

Air from the room enters the firebox, providing necessary oxygen for combustion. The damper, a movable plate within the flue, is opened to allow smoke and gases to escape when the fireplace is in use. Burning wood leaves behind ash, which must be regularly cleaned from the firebox to maintain airflow and combustion efficiency. Creosote, a tar-like substance, can accumulate in the chimney and must be cleaned regularly to prevent fire hazards.

Different Types of Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Superior WRT3042 42" Traditional Insulated Radiant Wood Burning Fireplace

Pictured: Superior WRT3042 42" Traditional Insulated Radiant Wood Burning Fireplace

Traditional Fireplaces: Built into the wall, often part of the home's original construction. They offer a classic ambiance with the sound and aroma of burning wood, typically requiring a chimney for ventilation.

Napoleon 41" S25I Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

Pictured: Napoleon 41" S25I Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

Inserts: Fits into an existing open fireplace, improving efficiency by providing a closed combustion system. They increase heat output and reduce heat loss up the chimney.

Majestic Castlewood 42" Traditional Outdoor Wood Burning Fireplace

Pictured: Majestic Castlewood 42" Traditional Outdoor Wood Burning Fireplace

Outdoor: Available in various styles like brick, stone, and portable fire pits, they serve as focal points for gatherings, providing warmth and charm. Proper installation and maintenance are crucial for safety.

Nectre N65 Wood Burning Stove

Pictured: Nectre N65 Wood Burning Stove

Stoves: Freestanding units made from cast iron or steel, offering high heat efficiency and a cozy atmosphere. Suitable for various rooms and connected to a chimney for ventilation.

Fire Pit Art 36" Antlers Fire Pit

Pictured: Fire Pit Art 36" Antlers Fire Pit

Fire Pits: Outdoor features designed for open-air settings. They provide a central gathering spot with the charm of a real wood fire and can be built-in or portable, available in various designs.

Mason-Lite 33" Pre-Cast Masonry Firebox Kit with 2ft Masonry Chimney

Pictured: Mason-Lite 33" Pre-Cast Masonry Firebox Kit with 2ft Masonry Chimney

Masonry Kits: DIY solutions for building custom fireplaces or fire pits. Kits include all necessary components and instructions, allowing homeowners to construct their own durable wood-burning features.

Ventis HEI350 30" Extra Large Size Black Direct Vent Wood Fireplace Insert, EPA2020 Certified

Pictured: Ventis HEI350 30" Extra Large Size Black Direct Vent Wood Fireplace Insert, EPA2020 Certified

Direct Vent: Uses a sealed combustion system, drawing air from outside for combustion and expelling exhaust back outside. They increase energy efficiency and keep combustion byproducts out of the living space.

Endless Summer 25" WAF1013C Black Wood Burning Outdoor Fireplace with Chimney

Pictured: Endless Summer 25" WAF1013C Black Wood Burning Outdoor Fireplace with Chimney

Ventless: Does not require external venting, designed to burn fuel cleanly and efficiently. Easy to install and can be placed almost anywhere in the home, though not allowed in some areas due to regulations.

True North TN20 38" Black Vented Wood Burning Insert, EPA2020 Certified

Pictured: True North TN20 38" Black Vented Wood Burning Insert, EPA2020 Certified

Vented: Use a chimney or flue system to expel combustion byproducts outside. They draw air from the room for combustion and expel exhaust through the venting system, offering a traditional fireplace experience.

Gas Fireplaces

Empire 36" Boulevard Vent-Free Linear Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Empire 36" Boulevard Vent-Free Linear Gas Fireplace

What is a Gas Fireplace?

A gas fireplace provides the charm and warmth of a traditional wood-burning fireplace, using natural gas or propane rather than wood. Known for their efficiency in quickly heating large spaces, gas fireplaces offer a clean burning experience without ash or soot.

Napoleon Altitude™ X 42" Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Napoleon Altitude™ X 42" Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

How Do Gas Fireplaces Work?

When activated, gas flows into the burner of the fireplace. This gas is ignited by either an electronic ignition or a pilot light system. The intensity of the flame and the heat output can then be controlled using the model's adjustable settings. To distribute the warmth evenly throughout the room, a blower system circulates the heated air.

Different Types of Gas Fireplaces

Napoleon B46 Ascent 46" Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Napoleon B46 Ascent 46" Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

Direct Vent: Uses a sealed combustion system that vents directly outdoors. It is safe and efficient, ideal for maintaining indoor air quality and versatile in installation locations.

Empire 37" Keystone Deluxe B-Vent Fireplace (Natural Gas)

Pictured: Empire 37" Keystone Deluxe B-Vent Fireplace (Natural Gas)

Ventless: Does not require external venting, allowing flexible installation. However, it raises concerns about indoor air quality due to emissions released into the room.

Majestic 36" Reveal Traditional Open Hearth B-Vent Gas Fireplace with IntelliFire Ignition System

Pictured: Majestic 36" Reveal Traditional Open Hearth B-Vent Gas Fireplace with IntelliFire Ignition System

B-vent: Uses natural venting through a chimney or pipe to the roof. It is less efficient as it uses indoor air for combustion, leading to heat loss, but is simpler and cost-effective.

Mason-Lite 36" Linear Gas Fireplace (No Trough)

Pictured: Mason-Lite 36" Linear Gas Fireplace (No Trough)

Linear: Features a slim, elongated opening with a modern aesthetic, often wall-mounted. Popular for their stylish appearance and ability to fit into narrow spaces.

Majestic Vesper 42" Traditional Outdoor Vent-Free Gas Fireplace With Herringbone Refractory

Picture: Majestic Vesper 42" Traditional Outdoor Vent-Free Gas Fireplace With Herringbone Refractory

Outdoor: Enhances your patio or deck with a warm, adjustable flame powered by natural gas or propane. Its sleek design adds a cozy ambiance, perfect for entertaining or relaxing outside.

Monessen 48" Artisan Vent Free See-Through Linear Fireplace with IPI Plus Ignition

Pictured: Monessen 48" Artisan Vent Free See-Through Linear Fireplace with IPI Plus Ignition

See-Through: Built into walls to provide a view from both sides, enhancing decorative appeal and serving as a central feature between two spaces, offering warmth and visual continuity.

Kingsman 23" FDV200S Free Standing Direct Vent Gas Stove

Pictured: Kingsman 23" FDV200S Free Standing Direct Vent Gas Stove

Stoves: Freestanding units resembling traditional wood stoves but using gas for heating. They combine the charm of old-world stoves with the convenience and cleanliness of gas.

The Outdoor GreatRoom Company 57" Denali Brew Linear Gas Fire Pit Table

Pictured: The Outdoor GreatRoom Company 57" Denali Brew Linear Gas Fire Pit Table

Fire Pits: Outdoor fixtures providing a central fire source, ideal for gatherings. They offer an open flame experience, perfect for entertaining, cooking, or relaxing outdoors.

Bromic Tungsten Smart-Heat 500 Series 25" Outdoor Gas Patio Heater

Pictured: Bromic Tungsten Smart-Heat 500 Series 25" Outdoor Gas Patio Heater

Heaters: Specifically designed for heating, rather than aesthetic purposes. Suitable for residential, commercial, or outdoor areas, focusing on efficient and targeted heat distribution.

Heating Capabilities & Area Coverage

Electric Fireplaces

Type of Electric Fireplace

Approximate BTU/hr

Area Coverage (sq. ft.)

Built-In Fireplaces

Up to 9,000

450

Electric Fireboxes

~ 4,000 - 9,000

200 - 450

See-Through Electric Fireplaces

~ 5,000 - 10,000

250 - 500

Electric Fireplace Inserts

~ 700 - 5,000

35 - 250

Water Vapors

Minimal heating unless combined with a heater accessory

Display only

Electric Stoves

~ 4,000 - 5,000

200 - 250

Linear Electric Fireplace

~ 5,000 - 10,000

250 - 500

Electric Fireplace Log Sets

~ 3,000 - 6,000

150 - 300

Electric Patio Heaters

~ 10,000 - 40,000

500 - 2,000

Electric fireplaces come in various types, each with different heating capabilities measured in BTUs per hour. These fireplaces can effectively heat up to 2,000 square feet, depending on the model and its heating capacity. Factors such as room size, layout, insulation, positioning, ceiling height, and window coverage can influence heating efficiency.

Heating Capacity by Model

  • Low-End Models: Produce around 700 to 1,500 BTUs per hour. Ideal for supplemental heating in small rooms or apartments.
  • Mid-Range Models: Generate between 4,000 and 9,000 BTUs per hour, suitable for heating individual rooms or moderately sized spaces.
  • High-End Models: Offer 10,000 to 40,000 BTUs per hour, powerful enough to heat larger areas or outdoor spaces.

Recommended BTU Output by Room Size

  • Up to 400 Square Feet: A smaller electric stove or insert with about 5,000 BTUs.
  • 400 to 600 Square Feet: Medium-sized fireplaces with BTU ratings of 5,000 to 10,000.
  • 600 to 900 Square Feet: Larger built-in or linear models with outputs ranging from 9,000 to 15,000 BTUs.
  • Outdoor Areas: Electric patio heaters may require more power, offering between 10,000 and 40,000 BTUs, depending on outdoor conditions and area size.

What are BTUs?


British Thermal Units (BTUs) is a measure of heat that indicates the energy required to heat or cool one pound (roughly 0.45 kilograms) of water. To calculate how many BTUs you need to warm up your room, simply multiply the square foot area of your space by 20 BTUs.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Type of Fireplace

Area Coverage

Efficiency

Fireplaces

400-1000 sq. ft.

10-20%

Inserts

1500-2000 sq. ft.

65-80%

Stoves

1000-3000 sq. ft.

70-85%

Fire Pits

100-200 sq. ft.

N/A

Masonry Kits

400-1000 sq. ft.

10-20%

Wood-burning fireplaces often have unpredictable heat output due to factors like the type and amount of wood, fireplace design, and chimney efficiency. Different wood species, their density, and moisture content significantly affect the heat produced. Well-seasoned hardwood generates more heat than green softwood. The design and efficiency of the fireplace and chimney also play crucial roles.

Open fireplaces are generally less efficient than wood stoves or inserts, leading to substantial variations in heat output. The efficiency of the burn can vary depending on how the fire is managed and the draft conditions. User-controlled factors, such as the amount of wood added, the size of the fire, and how often it is stoked, contribute to inconsistent and unpredictable heat output.

Heating Capacity by Fireplace Type

  • Fireplaces: These can cover an area of 400-1000 square feet with an efficiency rate of 10-20%.
  • Inserts: Inserts are capable of heating an area of 1500-2000 square feet with an efficiency rate of 65-80%.
  • Stoves: Stoves can heat areas ranging from 1000-3000 square feet with an efficiency rate of 70-85%.
  • Fire Pits: Fire pits typically cover an area of 100-200 square feet, though their efficiency is not applicable in the same way as indoor fireplaces.
  • Masonry Kits: Masonry kits can cover areas of 400-1000 square feet with an efficiency rate of 10-20%.

Manufacturers primarily focus on the safety of wood-burning fireplaces instead of defining an estimated heat output. Ensuring proper installation and safe operation is prioritized over providing a standardized BTU rating.

Unlike gas and electric fireplaces, which have controlled and predictable heat outputs, wood-burning fireplaces typically do not have BTU ratings due to these variables. Properly seasoned hardwoods like oak, maple, and hickory generally offer higher BTU outputs, making them more efficient for heating compared to softwoods like pine.

BTU Output by Wood Type

  • Oak: Oak provides 24 million BTUs per cord, being a high-density hardwood that burns slowly and provides steady heat.
  • Maple: Maple delivers 23 million BTUs per cord, characterized as a dense hardwood that burns hot and long, making it good for sustained heat.
  • Birch: Birch generates 21 million BTUs per cord, burning quickly and providing quick heat, though it is less long-lasting than oak or maple.
  • Pine: Pine offers 15 million BTUs per cord, being a softwood that burns quickly, making it more suited for kindling and quick fires.
  • Ash: Ash produces 20 million BTUs per cord, burning well even when not fully seasoned and providing steady heat.
  • Hickory: Hickory is one of the highest BTU-producing woods, delivering 28 million BTUs per cord, burning hot and long.
  • Cherry: Cherry yields 20 million BTUs per cord, burning slowly with a pleasant aroma and providing moderate heat output.
  • Walnut: Walnut offers 22 million BTUs per cord, burning slowly and providing steady heat while producing good coals.

Gas Fireplaces

Type of Gas Fireplace

Approximate BTU/hr

Area Coverage (sq. ft.)

Direct Vent Fireplaces

~ 20,000 - 50,000

1,000 - 2,500

Ventless Fireplaces

~ 5,000 - 40,000

250 - 2,500

B-vent Fireplaces

~ 20,000 - 50,000

1,000 - 1,500

Linear Fireplaces

~ 20,000 - 70,000

1,000 - 3,500

See-Through Fireplaces

~ 20,000 - 70,000

1,000 - 3,500

Gas Stoves 

~ 10,000 - 40,000

500 - 2,000

Gas Fire Pits

~ 30,000 - 110,000

1,500 - 5,500

Gas Heaters

~ 10,000 - 70,000

500 - 3,500

A typical gas fireplace can produce about 20,000 - 110,000 BTUs per hour, which is why they are ideal for open areas and large spaces. However, keep in mind that its BTU/hr highly depends on the type of fireplace.

Heating Capacity by Model

  • Ventless: Ventless models generate around 5,000 to 40,000 BTUs per hour. The lower end of this range (around 5,000 BTUs) is suitable for supplemental heating in small rooms or apartments.
  • Direct Vent and B-Vent: These models often produce between 20,000 and 50,000 BTUs per hour, making them adequate for heating individual rooms or moderately sized spaces.
  • Stoves and Heaters: Their output ranges from 10,000 to 70,000 BTUs per hour, fitting for medium spaces or as supplemental heat sources.
  • Linear and See-Through Fireplaces: These can output 20,000 to 70,000 BTUs per hour, powerful enough to heat larger areas or act as focal design elements in spacious environments.
  • Fire Pits: Fire pits can produce 30,000 to 110,000 BTUs per hour. This makes them ideal for outdoor spaces or large gathering areas.

Recommended BTU Output by Room Size

  • Up to 400 Square Feet: Smaller units like stoves or ventless models, typically outputting 250 to 500 BTUs, are sufficient for compact indoor spaces.
  • 400 to 600 Square Feet: Medium-sized fireplaces such as B-vent and smaller direct vent models, with BTU ratings from 1,000 to 1,500, are recommended for these areas.
  • 600 to 900 Square Feet: Larger built-in or linear models with outputs ranging from 1,000 to 3,000 BTUs will provide adequate warmth for more spacious rooms.
  • Outdoor Areas: Fire pits and large heaters, covering 1,500 to 5,000 square feet with 30,000 to 100,000 BTUs, are necessary to maintain comfortable temperatures in extensive outdoor spaces.

What are BTUs?

British Thermal Units (BTUs) is a measure of heat that indicates the energy required to heat or cool one pound (roughly 0.45 kilograms) of water. To calculate how many BTUs you need to warm up your room, simply multiply the square foot area of your space by 20 BTUs.

Winner: Gas Fireplaces

Winner: Gas Fireplaces

Gas fireplaces are superior to electric and wood-burning fireplaces due to their high heat output (20,000 - 110,000 BTU/hr), efficient heating for up to 3,500 sq. ft., and consistent performance. Unlike electric fireplaces, which are limited in heating capacity and often serve as supplemental heat, gas fireplaces provide robust heating for larger areas. Compared to wood-burning fireplaces, gas models offer easier maintenance, cleaner operation, and more predictable heat output without the need for constant wood supply and management.

Cost and Efficiency

Electric Fireplaces

Initial Cost

When purchasing an electric fireplace, the initial costs vary significantly depending on the type and features of the unit. These fireplaces come in various styles such as linear, built-in, and see-through models, each with its own price range.

Additional costs include installation, which may increase if extra wiring is required, and operating expenses associated with electricity use. If a new 120-volt outlet is needed, this too can add to the initial costs.

Type of Electric Fireplace

Price Range (USD)

Built-In Fireplaces

$549 - $9,999

Electric Fireboxes

$689 - $8,249

See-Through Electric Fireplaces

$959 - $2,899 

Electric Fireplace Inserts

$349 - $6,595

Water Vapors

$959 - $8,299

Electric Stoves

Starts at $1,999

Linear Electric Fireplace

$399 - $9,999

Electric Fireplace Log Sets

$103 - $799

Electric Patio Heaters

$69 - $4,717

Operating Cost

The energy use and hourly cost of an electric fireplace vary based on its mode of operation.

Using the fireplace at lower energy settings naturally results in decreased operational costs. When the heater is turned on, it typically uses about 1,500 watts (W) or 1.5 kilowatts (kWh) per hour. Conversely, utilizing the unit merely for its flame effect reduces the energy consumption to less than 300 W or 0.3 kWh.

For typical operation, with a unit consuming 1.5 kilowatts per hour at an average electricity rate of $0.12 per kWh, the cost would amount to approximately $0.18 per hour when the heating element is on.

For flame-only usage, which uses less than 300 watts, the operational cost is around $0.036 per hour. This economical consumption allows for all-year use without significantly affecting the electricity bill.

Electric fireplaces also offer cost savings over time compared to gas or wood fireplaces since they do not require annual maintenance such as chimney sweeping, inspections, or the storage of fuel, making them a cost-effective choice.

Below is a table outlining various electric fireplaces, detailing their energy consumption and estimated cost per hour. Keep in mind, however, that costs may vary based on local electricity rates.

Type of Electric Fireplace

Watts (W)

Kilowatts (kW)

Estimated Cost/hr

Built-In Fireplaces

750 - 1,500 W

0.75 - 1.50 KW

$0.11 - $0.22

Electric Fireboxes

1,350 - 1,650 W

1.35 - 1.65 kW

$0.20 - $0.25

See-Through Electric Fireplaces

1,500 - 1,800 W

1.50 - 1.80 kW

$0.22 - $0.27

Electric Fireplace Inserts

1,350 - 1,800 W

1.35 - 1.80 kW

$0.20 - $0.27

Water Vapors

150 - 460 W

0.15 - 0.46 kW

$0.02 - $0.07

Electric Stoves

750 - 1,500 W

0.75 - 1.50 kW

$0.11 - $0.22

Linear Electric Fireplace

1,500 - 3,000 W

1.50 - 3.00 kW

$0.22 - $0.45

Electric Fireplace Log Sets

900 - 1,500 W

0.90 - 1.50 kW

$0.14 - $0.22

Electric Patio Heaters

3,000 - 12,000 W

3.00 - 12.00 kW

$0.45 - $1.80

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Initial Cost

The upfront cost of installing a wood-burning fireplace can vary widely depending on the type and complexity of the installation.

  • Traditional Fireplaces: can range from modestly priced prefabricated units to expensive custom-built designs. These costs reflect not only the materials but also the labor involved in construction and installation.
  • Inserts: are designed to fit into existing fireplaces, making them a cost-effective way to upgrade older units. Their cost range takes into account the variety of styles and features available, such as blower fans, thermostatic controls, and more efficient burn technologies.
  • Stoves: offers a balance between functionality and aesthetics. They can serve as primary heat sources in smaller spaces, with initial costs reflecting the durability and heating capacity.
  • Fire Pits: are versatile and range from simple, portable models to elaborate built-in backyard features. The cost variation depends on the design complexity and materials used, such as metal, stone, or concrete.
  • Masonry Kits: provides a custom-built solution for those seeking a traditional look with modern efficiency. These kits include all necessary materials, but the labor-intensive nature of construction adds to the initial cost.

Below is a table containing each type of fireplace with their estimated initial costs. Keep in mind that prices may vary between manufacturers and authorized re-sellers.

Type of Fireplace

Estimated Initial Costs (USD)

Traditional Fireplaces

$229  - $21,558

Inserts

$717 - $5,399

Stoves

$1,556 - $6,859

Fire Pits

$103 - $7,700

Masonry Kits

$2,827 - $7,722

Operating Cost

Operating a traditional fireplace involves several ongoing expenses beyond the initial purchase and installation. Firewood costs can vary based on regional availability, type of wood (hardwood vs. softwood), and whether the wood is seasoned or unseasoned.

Frequent users may spend between $200 and $800+ annually on firewood. Chimney cleaning and maintenance are crucial for safety and efficiency, with professional sweeps recommending at least one cleaning per year to remove creosote buildup, costing between $100 and $300+ annually.

Cost Component

Estimated Annual Costs

Firewood

$200 - $800+

Chimney Cleaning and Maintenance

$100 - $300+

Ash Disposal

$50 - $150+

Firewood Storage

$50 - $200+

Additional Accessories

$50 - $150+

Inspection and Safety Checks

$50 - $150+

Proper ash disposal is necessary to maintain a clean and safe fireplace, adding another $50 to $150+ annually. Effective firewood storage solutions, ranging from simple outdoor racks to more elaborate sheds, may cost between $50 and $200+ annually. Investing in additional accessories such as fireplace screens, tool sets, and hearth rugs not only enhances safety but also contributes to the aesthetic appeal, costing around $50 to $150+ annually.

Regular inspections and safety checks are essential to ensure the fireplace and chimney are in good working order, preventing issues like carbon monoxide leaks and structural damage, and adding another $50 to $150+ annually. Different types of fireplaces have varying annual operating costs influenced by usage frequency, fuel type, and maintenance requirements. Traditional fireplaces, while offering a classic aesthetic, generally have higher operating costs due to regular maintenance, cleaning, and fuel needs, typically ranging from $500 to $1,750+ annually.

Freestanding wood stoves are known for their efficiency and advanced features that enhance burn efficiency and heat distribution, costing about $500 to $1,750+ annually. Outdoor fireplaces, requiring maintenance to withstand the elements, typically cost between $400 and $1,600+ annually.

Type of Fireplace

Estimated Total Annual Costs

Traditional Fireplace

$500 - $1,750+

Fireplace Insert

$500 - $1,750+

Freestanding Wood Stove

$500 - $1,750+

Outdoor Fireplace

$400 - $1,600+

Masonry Fireplace

$500 - $1,750+

Gas Fireplaces

Initial Cost

When considering the purchase of a gas fireplace, the initial financial commitment includes several key costs. Unit prices vary widely, typically ranging from $170 to $15,000, depending on the style and features of the fireplace.


Installation costs also vary significantly because they are influenced by the specific style of the fireplace and the complexity of the installation, which may involve structural modifications and ventilation setup.

Type of Gas Fireplace

Price Range (USD)

Direct Vent Fireplaces

$1,609 - $15,109

Ventless Fireplaces

$229 - $11,798

B-vent Fireplaces

$1,499 - $23,676

Linear Fireplaces

$1,260 - $23,676

See-Through Fireplaces

$2,869 - $12,919

Gas Stoves 

$949 - $4,599

Gas Fire Pits

$179 - $18,190

Gas Heaters

$66 - $10,701

Operational Cost

Gas fireplaces operate by burning fossil fuels such as natural gas or propane. Propane, a liquid form of petroleum gas, is derived from natural gas processing and is typically easier to store because it can be kept under lower pressure compared to natural gas, which is primarily methane and must be stored under high pressure due to its gaseous state.

Gas fireplaces, including direct vent and linear models, typically consume between 20,000 and 60,000 British Thermal Units (BTUs) per hour. With the average price of natural gas around $0.20 per therm (100,000 BTUs equal to one therm), the operating costs are estimated to be between $0.04 and $0.12 per hour when in use.

Additionally, gas fireplaces offer operational conveniences and lower maintenance compared to traditional wood-burning fireplaces. They eliminate the need for chimney cleaning or extensive inspections and do not require the handling and storage of wood. These factors contribute to cost savings and make gas fireplaces an economically attractive option over the long term.

The average running cost of a gas fireplace highly depends on the varying prices of fuel across the US. The table below shows the estimated cost of running a fireplace per hour. Note: This may vary depending on where you live.

Type of Gas Fireplace

Estimated Running Cost per Hour in $ (USD)

Direct Vent

~ $0.20 - $0.40

Ventless

~ $0.05 - $0.40

B-vent

~ $0.20 - $0.30

Linear

~ $0.20 - $0.60

See-Through

~ $0.20 - $0.50

Stoves

~ $0.10 - $0.30

Fire Pits

~ $0.30 - $1.00

Heaters

~ $0.10 - $0.50

Winner: Electric Fireplaces

Winner: Electric Fireplaces

Electric fireplaces win in terms of cost and efficiency due to their lower initial costs, minimal installation expenses, and economical operating costs. They offer a wide range of styles and prices, with models starting as low as $69 and up to $9,999 for high-end units.

Operating costs are also low, averaging about $0.18 per hour for heating and only $0.036 per hour for flame effects. Additionally, electric fireplaces do not require costly maintenance such as chimney sweeping or fuel storage, making them a more affordable and hassle-free heating solution compared to gas and wood-burning fireplaces.

Installation Options

Electric Fireplaces

Ambe Linear50 48" Built-in Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Ambe Linear50 48" Built-in Electric Fireplace

Recessed: Are fireplaces fitted directly into the wall. They are the most modern representation of traditional fireplaces seen in kitchens, large living rooms, or hallways. They do not provide very intense heat. However, this can be mitigated by placing a reflective surface above it.

Sierra Flame by Amantii Freestanding 26" Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Sierra Flame by Amantii Freestanding 26" Electric Fireplace

Freestanding: Are versatile appliances that comfortably fit in between furniture or in narrow areas. Because of this, they are perfect for people who live in apartments or those who have small living spaces.

SimpliFire INS30-BK 30" Traditional Electric Built-In Fireplace Insert

Pictured: SimpliFire INS30-BK 30" Traditional Electric Built-In Fireplace Insert

Inserts: Are commonly placed in unconventional areas such as porches, bathrooms, and large hallways. Just like any other electric fireplace, they are emission-free and non-allergenic.

Dimplex Sierra 72 Wall-MountTabletop Linear Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Dimplex Sierra 72 Wall-MountTabletop Linear Electric Fireplace

Wall-mounted: Ideal for small properties and rental spaces are areas where adding a sophisticated-looking fireplace can be difficult. However, you can now achieve a modern and cozy ambiance using wall-mounted electric fireplaces.

Touchstone Sideline 36" Flush Mount Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Touchstone Sideline 36" Flush Mount Electric Fireplace

Flush-Mount: Are designed to integrate seamlessly with the wall. These fireplaces sit flush against the wall, making it look like the fireplace is a part of the main structure. It fits minimalistic styles of rooms the best, as it does not consume a lot of space.

 Modern Flames 30" Sedona Pro Multi-Sided Built-in Clean Face Electric Fireplace

Pictured: Modern Flames 30" Sedona Pro Multi-Sided Built-in Clean Face Electric Fireplace

2-Sided: Can be seen integrated into walls and can be viewed from two sides. This provides visual aesthetics and heat to two different rooms simultaneously, which is perfect for creating focal points in large or open floor plans.

European Home 60" Linnea 3-Sided Built-In Electric Fireplace with Halo Burner Technology

Pictured: European Home 60" Linnea 3-Sided Built-In Electric Fireplace with Halo Burner Technology

3-Sided: Offers a panoramic view of the flames from three sides of the fireplace. Similar to 2-sided fireplaces, they are often used as statement pieces in modern rooms. It also offers broader heat distribution.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Majestic 42" Designer Series See-Through Radiant Wood Burning Fireplace

Pictured: Majestic 42" Designer Series See-Through Radiant Wood Burning Fireplace

See-through: Also known as double-sided fireplaces, are installed between two rooms, allowing the flames to be viewed from both sides. This design not only provides warmth but also serves as a stylish room divider, adding a unique visual element to the home.

Breckwell 27" SW1.8 Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

Pictured: Breckwell 27" SW1.8 Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

Built-in: Are integrated into the wall or a custom mantel, creating a seamless and sophisticated look. They are ideal for new construction or major remodeling projects.

Superior WRE3042 42" Traditional Outdoor Wood Burning Fireplace With White Stacked Refractory Panels

Pictured: Superior WRE3042 42" Traditional Outdoor Wood Burning Fireplace With White Stacked Refractory Panels

Wall-mounted: Are installed directly onto the wall, making them a perfect choice for rooms with limited floor space. They are available in various styles, from sleek, modern designs to more traditional looks.

Malm Zircon 34” Matte Black Freestanding Wood Burning Fireplace

Pictured: Malm Zircon 34” Matte Black Freestanding Wood Burning Fireplace

Freestanding: Are standalone units that do not require any installation into the wall or floor. They can be easily moved and placed in different locations within the home. Freestanding fireplaces come in a range of styles, including stoves and contemporary designs, that is sure to fit any home decor or aesthetic.

Gas Fireplaces

Monessen 33" Solstice Traditional Style Vent Free Gas Insert Fireplace

Pictured: Monessen 33" Solstice Traditional Style Vent Free Gas Insert Fireplace

Inserts:  Are perfect for homeowners who would like to upgrade their traditional fireplaces into clean-burning systems. These inserts are designed to fit snugly into any existing fireplace and utilize the venting system or chimney.

Empire Carol Rose 60" Manual Control, 70K/40K BTU Outdoor Linear See-Thru Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Empire Carol Rose 60" Manual Control, 70K/40K BTU Outdoor Linear See-Thru Gas Fireplace

Built-In: Are integrated into the main structure of your home. Unlike the other fireplaces from this list, they require some home modifications to install venting systems. As a result, this fireplace is ideal for homes that are yet to be constructed.

Superior DRL3545 45" Linear Contemporary Direct Vent Natural Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Superior DRL3545 45" Linear Contemporary Direct Vent Natural Gas Fireplace

Wall-mount: Are mounted on the wall are popular for their modern appeal and space-saving design. They provide both ambiance and functionality with minimal intrusion and fewer home modifications. These fireplaces can also be placed in rooms without chimneys or vets.

Sierra Flame by Amantii 36" Boston Linear Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Sierra Flame by Amantii 36" Boston Linear Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

Flush-mount: Similar to built-in fireplaces, these fireplaces are designed to be integrated seamlessly into walls. Because of this, they require precise planning and construction to ensure everything is correctly fitted into the wall. After the modification, you are left with clean, modern, and minimalist aesthetics.

Faber MatriX 4326 Series Two-sided Right-facing Built-in Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Faber MatriX 4326 Series Two-sided Right-facing Built-in Gas Fireplace

2-sided: Displays flames from both sides. As such, they are usually built into wall dividers between rooms to efficiently heat both rooms at once.

Kingsman 43" MCVP42 Multi-sided Clean View Peninsula Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

Pictured: Kingsman 43" MCVP42 Multi-sided Clean View Peninsula Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

3-sided: Are for those who love to make dramatic impacts. These fireplaces are placed in strategic locations around your home to serve as a centerpiece during family events or social gatherings. Due to the three open sides, 3-sided fireplaces provide widespread warmth throughout the room.

Malm Spin-A-Fire 32" Freestanding Propane Gas Fireplace With Remote Control, RAL 1000 49/15200 Powder Coat Top and Matte Black Base

Pictured: Malm Spin-A-Fire 32" Freestanding Propane Gas Fireplace With Remote Control, RAL 1000 49/15200 Powder Coat Top and Matte Black Base

Freestanding: Can be positioned and moved anytime and anywhere. They do not require rebuilding or remodeling, making them versatile and easy to install.

Winner: It’s a Tie

Winner: It’s a Tie

It's a tie because electric, wood-burning, and gas fireplaces all offer versatile installation options, including recessed, freestanding, inserts, wall-mounted, flush-mount, and multi-sided designs, catering to different home styles, space requirements, and aesthetic preferences.

 

Maintenance and Care

Electric Fireplaces

Maintenance and Care of Electric Fireplaces

Safety and Preparation

Before you begin any maintenance on your electric fireplace, it's essential to ensure it's completely turned off to avoid the risk of electric shocks. For plug-in models, switch off the power at the outlet and unplug the unit. If your fireplace is hardwired, disconnect it from your home's fuse box. Allow the unit to cool down fully if it has been in use recently.

Replacing Light Bulbs

After the fireplace has cooled, refer to the owner’s manual or search online using your model number to locate the light bulbs. These are usually positioned at the back and may require removing a panel with a screwdriver. Handle the bulbs with gloves or a cloth to avoid oil transfer from your hands. Unscrew the old bulbs counterclockwise and install the new ones by turning them clockwise to ensure they are securely fitted.

Cleaning the Exterior

Begin with the exterior, including the glass and any visible surfaces. Use a damp cloth dipped in warm, soapy water, avoiding any flammable cleaning agents. Thoroughly wipe and then dry the exterior to prevent water spots. In between deep cleanings, routinely dust the surface with a dry cloth.

Cleaning the Ember Bed and Heater Vents

Dust buildup on the ember bed and heater vents can affect both the look and function of your fireplace. Clean the ember bed with a damp cloth, and vacuum away any excess dust if necessary. The heater vents, usually found at the base of the unit, should be kept dust-free to prevent overheating. Wipe these down gently with a damp cloth.

Cleaning the Fan and Interior Components

If the fan behind the front grille looks dirty or isn't spinning smoothly, it’s time for a clean. Use a small brush and a vacuum with a wand attachment to carefully remove dust from the fan blades and accessible interior parts. For sensitive components like the blower and flame-effect mechanisms, use a dry microfiber cloth to avoid moisture damage. These parts, including any mirrors, motorized rods, or light sources, should be handled gently to prevent any damage.

Additional Maintenance Tips

  • Avoid Electrical Hazards: Ensure that no water sources or potential electrical hazards are near your fireplace.
  • Secure Outlets: Check that the electrical outlet is suitable for the load of your fireplace to avoid blown fuses and refrain from plugging other devices into the same outlet.
  • Avoid Flammable Objects: Keep flammable materials at a safe distance from your electric fireplace. Regularly dust both the interior and exterior to reduce fire risks.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Maintenance and Care of Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Preparation

Before starting any maintenance on your wood-burning fireplace, ensure it is completely cool. Remove any leftover ash and debris from the firebox using a fireplace shovel and a metal container. Make sure to wear gloves and protective eyewear to prevent injury.

Cleaning the Firebox

Begin by removing the grate and any remaining ash. Sweep out the firebox using a fireplace broom. For a deeper clean, use a mixture of water and mild detergent to scrub the walls and floor of the firebox. Rinse thoroughly and allow it to dry completely before use.

Cleaning the Glass Doors

If your fireplace has glass doors, clean them using a mixture of water and vinegar or a specialized fireplace glass cleaner. Use a soft cloth or sponge to avoid scratching the glass. For stubborn soot marks, use a fireplace glass cleaner, then wipe off the residue with a clean, damp cloth. Thoroughly dry the glass with paper towels or newspapers to prevent streaks.

Chimney Maintenance

Inspect your chimney for creosote buildup, which can be a fire hazard. Use a chimney brush to clean the flue. For best results, hire a professional chimney sweep annually to ensure thorough cleaning and inspection. Check for any blockages or damage in the chimney that may need professional attention.

Log Care

Use only seasoned hardwoods for burning, as unseasoned or softwoods can cause excessive creosote buildup. Store your firewood in a dry, well-ventilated area to keep it seasoned and ready for use. Avoid using painted or treated wood as it can release harmful chemicals when burned.

Fireplace Surround and Mantel

Dust the fireplace surround and mantel regularly to keep them clean. For stone or brick surrounds, use a mixture of water and mild detergent for cleaning. For wooden mantels, use a wood cleaner or polish to maintain their appearance.

Ash Disposal

Dispose of ashes in a metal container with a lid, and store it outside away from any flammable materials. Ensure the ashes are completely cool before disposing of them to prevent accidental fires.

Safety Check

Regularly check the fireplace for any signs of wear or damage. Ensure the fireplace screen or door is in good condition to prevent sparks from escaping. Install a carbon monoxide detector and smoke detector near the fireplace and test them regularly to ensure they are functioning properly.

Additional Maintenance Tips

  • Damper: Check to ensure it opens and closes properly.
  • Chimney Cap: Inspect for damage or blockages.
  • Annual Inspections: Schedule for both your fireplace and chimney in late summer or early fall to prepare for the heating season.
  • Fire Extinguisher: Keep nearby for emergencies.
  • Fireplace Grate: Always use to elevate the logs and ensure proper air circulation.
  • Carbon Monoxide Detector: Install near the fireplace and test regularly.
  • Smoke Detector: Install near the fireplace and test regularly.
  • Fireplace Screen/Door: Ensure it is in good condition to prevent sparks from escaping.

Gas Fireplaces

Maintenance and Care of Gas Fireplaces

Preparation

Before starting any maintenance on your gas fireplace, read the manufacturer’s manual carefully, especially the safety warnings. Switch off the pilot light, close the gas valve to stop the flow of gas, and allow the fireplace to cool completely before beginning cleaning or disassembly.

Disassembly

Once the fireplace is cool, begin disassembly for a thorough cleaning. Remove the glass panel as specified in the owner’s manual. If necessary, remove decorative logs using tools like a screwdriver. Place these parts on a soft surface like a drop cloth or an old towel to prevent damage. Taking a photo before disassembly can help with accurate reassembly.

Cleaning the Glass

To clean the glass doors, place them on old newspapers or a plastic sheet to protect the underlying surface. Use a soft cloth and household window cleaner for general cleaning. For stubborn soot marks, use a small amount of fireplace or ceramic cooktop cleaner, then wipe off the residue with a clean, damp cloth. Thoroughly dry the glass with paper towels or newspapers to prevent streaks, then reattach the doors. Wait at least 30 minutes before using the fireplace to ensure all cleaners have evaporated.

Interior Maintenance

Use the wand attachment of your vacuum cleaner to remove dust and debris from inside the fireplace. If your fireplace contains small lava rocks, cover the vacuum wand with cheesecloth or an old stocking secured with a rubber band to prevent them from being sucked up. This makeshift filter allows for safe cleaning without losing the rocks.

Log Care

Gas log sets generally require minimal maintenance. If soot accumulates on vented gas logs, remove them according to the manual, take them outside, and gently brush off the soot using a soft-bristled brush like a paintbrush. Do not wash or damp-wipe the logs, as moisture can damage their finish. For vent-free logs, avoid moving or cleaning them yourself; only a qualified service technician should handle these due to potential safety risks.

Battery Replacement

Replace the batteries in your fireplace remotes twice a year, similar to maintaining your smoke and carbon monoxide detectors. This ensures you can shut down the fireplace quickly if necessary.

Additional Maintenance Tips

  • Determine Type of Fireplace: Determine the type of fireplace you have before cleaning.
  • Vent-Free Fireplaces Caution: Limit their use as they consume oxygen from the room.
  • Inspect Faux Logs and Rocks: Regularly inspect for discoloration, wear, or cracks, and replace them as needed.
  • Carbon Monoxide Detector: Ensure a working detector is installed nearby.
  • Look for Damage Signs: Look for excess moisture or cracked paint around the fireplace, and contact a professional if these issues are observed.
  • Annual Inspections: Schedule for both your fireplace and chimney in late summer or early fall to prepare for the heating season.

Winner: Electric Fireplaces

Winner: Electric Fireplaces

Electric fireplaces win in maintenance and care due to their simplicity and low upkeep. Unlike wood-burning fireplaces, they don't require regular chimney cleaning, ash disposal, or firewood storage, which can be time-consuming and costly.

Compared to gas fireplaces, electric models avoid the need for professional inspections or handling potentially hazardous gas connections. Cleaning an electric fireplace involves basic tasks like dusting, wiping down surfaces, and occasionally replacing light bulbs, making them the most convenient and low-maintenance option.

Environmental Impact

Electric Fireplaces

Environmental Impact of Electric Fireplaces

Electric fireplaces present a sustainable heating option with high energy efficiency, zero emissions, and the potential to use renewable energy sources. Their advanced features and low maintenance needs further enhance their environmental benefits, making them an excellent choice for eco-conscious homeowners.

Energy Efficiency

Electric fireplaces are known for their high energy efficiency, as nearly all the electrical energy is converted into heat. This makes them a highly efficient heating option, especially when compared to traditional fireplaces that lose a significant amount of heat through the chimney.

No Emissions

Electric fireplaces produce no direct emissions, making them an environmentally friendly choice. They do not release carbon monoxide, particulate matter, or other pollutants into the air, contributing to better indoor and outdoor air quality.

Renewable Energy Compatibility

Electric fireplaces can be powered by renewable energy sources. By choosing a renewable energy provider or using solar panels to generate electricity, you can further reduce the environmental impact of heating your home.

Low Maintenance

Electric fireplaces require minimal maintenance, reducing the need for cleaning chemicals and materials. This not only saves resources but also lessens the environmental footprint associated with upkeep.

Innovative Technologies

Modern electric fireplaces come with advanced features like adjustable flame effects, programmable thermostats, and remote controls. These technologies allow for precise control over energy usage, optimizing efficiency and reducing waste.

Environmental Regulations

Electric fireplaces comply with stringent energy efficiency standards and regulations. By choosing models that are ENERGY STAR® certified, you can ensure that your fireplace meets high environmental and efficiency criteria.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Environmental Impact of Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Wood-burning fireplaces can be a sustainable heating option when used responsibly. By selecting sustainably sourced firewood, utilizing modern, efficient technologies, and adhering to environmental regulations, you can enjoy the warmth and ambiance of a wood fire while minimizing your ecological footprint.

Sustainable Firewood Choices

Selecting firewood from sustainably managed forests is crucial. Look for certifications like the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) to ensure your wood is responsibly sourced. Using dried wood with a moisture content of less than 20% not only burns more efficiently but also produces less smoke. Additionally, buying locally sourced wood minimizes transportation emissions and supports local economies.

Efficiency and Emissions

Modern wood-burning fireplaces, stoves, and inserts have come a long way in terms of efficiency. EPA-certified products can achieve up to 80% efficiency, significantly reducing emissions compared to traditional open fireplaces. Good ventilation and burning small, hot fires with dry wood enhance combustion efficiency and lower pollutant output. This makes modern wood-burning solutions a more sustainable option.

Carbon Neutrality

One of the main sustainability advantages of wood is its carbon neutrality. When wood is burned, it releases the same amount of carbon dioxide that it absorbed during its growth, making it a balanced cycle. Supporting reforestation efforts or planting trees can offset the carbon impact of your wood use. For those who gather their own firewood, practicing selective cutting and allowing for regrowth ensures the sustainability of the resource.

Innovative Technologies

Advancements in technology have made wood-burning more sustainable. Wood stoves equipped with catalytic combustors significantly reduce emissions. Smart control systems in modern fireplaces optimize burning conditions, enhancing efficiency and minimizing waste.

Environmental Regulations

Adhering to environmental regulations is essential for sustainable wood-burning. Choosing EPA-certified products ensures compliance with stringent emission standards. It's also important to follow local regulations and burn bans to minimize environmental impact.

Gas Fireplaces

Environmental Impact of Gas Fireplaces

Gas fireplaces offer a sustainable heating option with high efficiency, lower emissions, and advanced technologies that enhance control and reduce fuel consumption. While they still rely on fossil fuels, their cleaner burning nature and technological advancements make them a more environmentally friendly choice compared to traditional wood-burning fireplaces.

Efficient Fuel Use

Gas fireplaces, whether using natural gas or propane, are highly efficient, often converting up to 90% of the fuel into usable heat. This efficiency reduces waste and ensures that more of the energy produced is used to heat your home rather than being lost.

Lower Emissions

Compared to wood-burning fireplaces, gas fireplaces produce significantly fewer particulate emissions. Natural gas and propane burn cleaner, emitting less carbon monoxide, particulate matter, and other pollutants. This makes gas fireplaces a more environmentally friendly choice in terms of air quality.

Carbon Footprint

While gas is a fossil fuel and its combustion releases carbon dioxide, it burns more cleanly than coal or oil. Additionally, advancements in technology have led to the development of highly efficient gas fireplaces that maximize heat output while minimizing fuel consumption. Opting for a high-efficiency, direct-vent gas fireplace can further reduce your carbon footprint.

Innovative Technologies

Modern gas fireplaces come with features like programmable thermostats, remote controls, and timers that allow for better control over fuel usage. This not only enhances convenience but also contributes to energy savings and efficiency.

Environmental Regulations

Gas fireplaces are subject to strict environmental regulations aimed at minimizing emissions. By choosing models that meet or exceed these standards, you can ensure that your fireplace has a lower environmental impact.

Environmental Regulations

Gas fireplaces are subject to strict environmental regulations aimed at minimizing emissions. By choosing models that meet or exceed these standards, you can ensure that your fireplace has a lower environmental impact.

Winner: Electric Fireplaces

Winner: Electric Fireplaces

Electric fireplaces win in terms of environmental impact due to their high energy efficiency, zero emissions, compatibility with renewable energy sources, and minimal maintenance needs. They convert nearly all electrical energy into heat, avoiding the significant heat loss associated with traditional fireplaces. Additionally, they produce no direct emissions, such as carbon monoxide or particulate matter, improving both indoor and outdoor air quality.

Electric fireplaces can also be powered by renewable energy, further reducing their environmental footprint. Their advanced features and low upkeep requirements minimize resource use and waste, making them the most eco-friendly heating option compared to wood-burning and gas fireplaces.

Ambiance and Aesthetics

Electric Fireplaces

Ambiance and Aesthetics Electric Fireplaces
  • Flame Customization: Customizable flame colors, patterns, and intensities.
  • Realism: Realistic flame effects using LED technology.
  • Styles: Variety of styles including wall-mounted, built-in, and freestanding units.
  • Media Kits: Optional media kits like crystals, logs, and stones for enhanced visual appeal.
  • Design: Sleek, modern designs that blend with contemporary décor.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Ambiance and Aesthetics of Wood-Burning Fireplaces
  • Authentic Ambiance: Authentic and traditional ambiance with real flames and crackling sounds.
  • Styles: Available as masonry, inserts, stoves, and fire pits.
  • Customization: Various mantel, surround, and accessory options.
  • Charm: Rustic and cozy appeal.
  • Focal Point: Enhances traditional and rustic home designs.

Gas Fireplaces

Ambiance and Aesthetics of Gas Fireplaces
  • Realism: Realistic flames and glowing embers that mimic a wood fire.
  • Styles: Available in traditional, contemporary, and transitional styles.
  • Customization: Wide range of logs, glass, and stone media options.
  • Installation Options: Options for see-through, corner, and outdoor installations.
  • Decorative Elements: Decorative fronts, surrounds, and mantels.

 

Winner: Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Winner: Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Wood-burning fireplaces win in ambiance and aesthetics due to their authentic and traditional feel, complete with real flames and crackling sounds that create a warm, cozy atmosphere. They offer a variety of styles, including masonry, inserts, stoves, and fire pits, and can be customized with different mantels, surrounds, and accessories.

This rustic charm and natural appeal make wood-burning fireplaces a focal point in traditional and rustic home designs, providing a unique and inviting aesthetic that electric and gas fireplaces can't fully replicate.

 

Safety Considerations and Features

Electric Fireplaces

Safety Considerations and Features of Electric Fireplaces
  • Cool-to-Touch Glass: Safe operation with cool-to-touch glass.
  • No Combustion: No real flames or combustion, reducing fire risk.
  • Overheat Protection: Automatic shutoff if the unit overheats.
  • Child Lock: Child safety locks on some models to prevent accidental operation.
  • No Emissions: No harmful emissions or carbon monoxide.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Safety Considerations and Features of Wood-Burning Fireplaces
  • Chimney Maintenance: Regular chimney inspections and sweeping to prevent creosote buildup.
  • Fire Screens: Protective screens to prevent sparks from escaping.
  • Carbon Monoxide Detectors: Essential for detecting harmful gases.
  • Proper Venting: Ensures smoke and gases are safely expelled.
  • Fireplace Tools: Tools for safe handling of logs and embers.

Gas Fireplaces

Safety Considerations and Features of Gas Fireplaces
  • Carbon Monoxide Detectors: Built-in carbon monoxide detectors for safety.
  • Glass Barriers: Protective glass barriers to prevent burns.
  • Automatic Shutoff: Safety shutoff valve if the pilot light goes out.
  • Ventilation: Proper ventilation systems to ensure safe operation.
  • Flame Supervision Device: Monitors and controls the gas flow to prevent leaks.

Winner: Electric Fireplaces

Winner: Electric Fireplaces

Electric fireplaces win in safety considerations and features due to their inherently safe operation with no real flames or combustion, reducing the risk of fire. They feature cool-to-touch glass, overheat protection with automatic shutoff, and child safety locks on some models, ensuring safe use around children and pets.

Additionally, electric fireplaces produce no harmful emissions or carbon monoxide, eliminating the need for ventilation or carbon monoxide detectors. These safety features make electric fireplaces the safest option compared to wood-burning and gas fireplaces.

 

FAQs

FAQs

How do I decide which fireplace is right for my home?

Consider your space, budget, heating needs, and personal preferences. Electric fireplaces are great for easy installation and modern aesthetics, wood-burning fireplaces offer a traditional ambiance, and gas fireplaces provide efficient and convenient heating.

What are the long-term costs associated with each type of fireplace?

Electric fireplaces offer low maintenance and operational costs but are dependent on electricity prices. Wood-burning fireplaces require high maintenance, incur costs for firewood, chimney cleaning, and potential repairs. Gas fireplaces have moderate operational costs depending on gas prices and require occasional maintenance.

Are there any tax credits or incentives for installing certain types of fireplaces?

Some regions offer tax credits or incentives for installing energy-efficient fireplaces, particularly those that use renewable resources like wood or are highly efficient gas models. Check local regulations and incentives.

How do different fireplaces affect home value?

Fireplaces generally add value to a home. Wood-burning and gas fireplaces can increase a home's appeal, especially in colder climates, by offering a traditional or efficient heating source. Electric fireplaces can enhance modern homes with their convenience and aesthetic appeal.

What safety features should I look for in a fireplace?

Look for features like cool-to-touch glass, automatic shutoff, carbon monoxide detectors, and proper ventilation systems. Electric fireplaces should have overheat protection, while gas fireplaces should have flame supervision devices and glass barriers.

Can I use a fireplace during a power outage?

Wood-burning fireplaces can be used during power outages as they do not rely on electricity. Some gas fireplaces with battery backup or manual ignition can also be used. Electric fireplaces will not function without power.

The Verdict

Choosing the right fireplace for your home depends on your lifestyle, preferences, and needs. Electric fireplaces offer modern convenience, safety, and low maintenance, making them ideal for urban settings and contemporary interiors.

Wood-burning fireplaces provide a timeless, authentic ambiance with crackling flames and the aroma of burning wood, perfect for those who appreciate a traditional, rustic feel. Gas fireplaces strike a balance between convenience and authenticity, delivering real flames and consistent heat with minimal upkeep.

Consider the pros and cons, costs, installation requirements, and environmental impacts of each type to make an informed decision. Whether you're seeking the cutting-edge technology of electric fireplaces, the nostalgic charm of wood-burning hearths, or the efficient heat of gas units, there's a perfect fireplace waiting to become the heart of your home.

Top Brands

Electric Fireplaces

Amantii 100" Symmetry 3.0 Extra Tall Built-in Smart WiFi Electric Fireplace

In Picture: Amantii 100" Symmetry 3.0 Extra Tall Built-in Smart WiFi Electric Fireplace

  • Dimplex: Is one of the leading manufacturers of electric fireplaces. Known for its innovation, Dimplex offers a wide range of models including built-ins, inserts, and freestanding units. They often lead the market in terms of realistic flame technology and energy-efficient heating.
  • Amantii: Is a luxury brand known for its high-quality electric fireplaces that come in a variety of modern designs. They offer features such as multi-colored flame effects and unique glass media. Amantii focuses on contemporary aesthetics, making them popular in modern homes and commercial spaces.
  • SimpliFire: Produces a variety of electric fireplaces that are easy to install and maintain. Their products range from wall-mount models to built-in units, emphasizing simplicity and user convenience. They are often appreciated for their cost-effectiveness and functional designs.
  • Modern Flames: Is renowned for its modern and innovative designs in electric fireplaces. They offer a variety of models, including linear and landscape series. Their fireplaces are often chosen for their realistic flame patterns and chic, contemporary appearances.
  • Touchstone: Specializes in electric fireplaces that are both affordable and stylish. They offer a wide range of products including wall-mounted and recessed models that are ideal for residential and commercial settings. Touchstone fireplaces are known for their ease of use and installation.

Wood-Burning Fireplaces

Valcourt Waterloo-Arched High-Efficiency Faceplate Wood Fireplace

Pictured: Valcourt Waterloo-Arched High-Efficiency Faceplate Wood Fireplace

  • Majestic: Are known for their traditional charm and robust construction. They offer various models that cater to both aesthetic preferences and heating needs. Key features often include a large viewing area, efficient heating capabilities, and options for customizing the look with different finishes and accessories.
  • Valcourt: Are designed with a focus on high efficiency and eco-friendliness. These Canadian-made fireplaces are crafted to deliver maximum heat output while minimizing emissions. Valcourt models are often equipped with advanced combustion technology, ensuring cleaner burns and compliance with environmental standards.
  • Superior Fireplaces: Are known for their combination of durability and design flexibility. They provide a range of models suitable for different home styles, from traditional to modern. Superior fireplaces are built with high-quality materials and offer features such as adjustable air controls, large glass doors, and various finishing options to enhance the fireplace's appearance.
  • Osburn: Are renowned for their powerful heating capabilities and sturdy construction. Ideal for those seeking both warmth and ambiance, Osburn  models often feature high-efficiency designs, large fireboxes, and sophisticated air wash systems that keep the glass clean. They are well-suited for heating large spaces efficiently.
  • Napoleon: Blends innovative technology with traditional aesthetics. They offer a variety of models that emphasize efficiency and ease of use. Napoleon fireplaces typically feature secondary combustion systems for cleaner burns, easy-to-use controls, and stylish design elements that can complement any home decor.

Gas Fireplaces

Majestic Vesper 36" Traditional Outdoor Vent-Free Gas Fireplace With Traditional Stacked Refractory

In Picture: Majestic Vesper 36" Traditional Outdoor Vent-Free Gas Fireplace With Traditional Stacked Refractory

  • Empire Comfort Systems: Has been a respected manufacturer of gas fireplaces for many years. They are known for their durable, efficient, and aesthetically pleasing products, including vent-free and direct-vent models. Empire often focuses on creating products that offer robust heating solutions with traditional and rustic aesthetics.
  • Majestic: Produces a wide range of high-quality gas fireplaces that are both beautiful and functional. They offer models with innovative controls and flame technology. Majestic is recognized for its expansive offerings from basic to high-end models, suiting various home styles and preferences.
  • Monessen: Is known for its focus on safety, efficiency, and versatile designs. Their products are designed to provide significant heat output while being easy to install and maintain, making them popular among homeowners looking for an effective heating solution with a minimal footprint.
  • Superior Fireplaces: Offers a broad array of gas fireplaces, including both traditional and contemporary designs. Their products are known for durability, aesthetic appeal, and the incorporation of modern technologies in fireplaces. Superior’s models often feature innovative flame effects and customizable options.
  • Napoleon: Is a well-known brand in the fireplace industry, celebrated for its high-quality and innovative gas fireplaces. They offer a wide variety of models that include luxury features, such as adjustable flame and heat settings, remote controls, and energy-efficient designs. Napoleon fireplaces are designed to provide visual appeal and effective heating with a touch of sophistication.

Where To Buy?

Can’t seem to find the perfect fireplace?

Browse our extensive collection today, compare your options, and find the fireplace that not only meets your heating needs but also enhances the comfort and style of your home.

🔥 Shop at US Fireplace Store’s extensive collection of gas, wood-burning, and electric fireplaces now, and transform your home the way you like it!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.